Back to News Page for 2005 ... Braddock Images 1 and Two .. The Depression .. Life Magazine .. Articles (Historic) ..Biography 1 and Two .. Literature .. Links .. News Snippets .. In Braddock's Own Words .. From fans: Personal Memories of the Depression ... Crowe Images ... Older News ... Cast images ... The Championship Fight ... Paintings and Photographs - NYC ... Misc Press Articles ... Russell answers questions on CM ... Fan Reports ... Fan Reviews ... News Main

Fan Reviews - Some may contain spoilers....


 

5/5/05 - Cinderella Man is not the film you’d expect going in. One might expect a real-life version of Rocky, with even more sentimentality. But that is not what this film offers. Instead we get a vivid look into both the Great Depression, and boxing. We see the big differences between our little recession in the early part of this decade and the hopeless nature of the collapse of the 1930s. The deep look into that part of Jim Braddock’s story makes the boxing scenes stand out so much more for their vividness and accuracy. One feels as if they are in the depression, and one feels as if they are getting hit in the ring.

Russell Crowe portrays the dogged, moral determination of James J. Braddock with no flaws. As usual. Honesty is the touchstone of this character. And Paul Giamatti’s cornerman character works perfectly off the easy stillness of Crowe’s character. Renee Zellweger is making a habit of humorous, strong, and soft heroines, and this film is no different, but that’s not to say that she is phoning in the role. It is a perfect counterpart to Crowe’s Braddock.

Very well done, and Oscar-worthy. - -C

5/4/05 - I was one of the lucky ones in Denver to receive passes to see this movie last night. Ron Howard has done it again. Russell Crowe is absolutely amazing as Braddock and Paul Giamatti is equally impressive. One of the rare times you will see a “period” movie and feel like you are actually watching the story take place as it happens. I couldn’t help but think about “Rocky” while I was watching. The story is true so it makes you wonder if Sly Stallone didn’t pattern his movie after James Braddock. What an inspirational story. In the age of greedy athletes today, it’s incredible to see a true “Rags to Riches” story about a great man not only in the ring but in his personal life as well. I would give this movie 5 out of 5 stars. -- D. Brad Hahn

Back to CM News